Fall in love with critical customers

A critical customer can reveal a problem that a business has stopped noticing. A confusing invoice, a late delivery or an unanswered message may appear minor inside the company while creating a frustrating experience for the person affected. Taking that complaint seriously gives the organisation a chance to understand and improve the service.

Jay Baer explores this subject in Hug Your Haters: How to Embrace Complaints and Keep Your Customers. His argument encourages businesses to engage with complaints instead of avoiding them. That does not mean every accusation is correct, or that staff must accept abuse. It means feedback deserves an organised, thoughtful response.

Acknowledge the actual problem

A useful first reply shows that somebody has read the complaint. Refer to the specific issue rather than sending a cheerful message that could apply to anything. If an order arrived incomplete, acknowledge the missing items before explaining what information is needed.

Thanking the customer can be appropriate, but it should not sound like a technique for distracting them. An apology also needs to match what is known. You can recognise inconvenience while investigating the facts, without inventing an explanation or assigning blame prematurely.

For example, a café receiving a complaint about a cold meal could ask when the visit occurred and offer a direct contact for follow-up. A long public defence of the kitchen’s usual standards would leave the original problem unanswered.

Give the next step an owner

Customers should not have to discover which department is responsible. Decide who will investigate, what they need and when the customer can expect an update. If another team takes over, pass along the relevant information so the person does not need to repeat the entire story.

Promises should reflect what the business can deliver. A clear update tomorrow is more credible than an immediate resolution promised without checking. When the investigation takes longer, explain the delay and provide a revised expectation.

Keep a record of the issue and the action agreed. This helps distinguish a case that received a polite reply from one that was actually resolved. Sending a message is a step in the process, not necessarily its conclusion.

Respond where the complaint appears

A public complaint often has an audience beyond the customer involved. A calm initial response can show others how the business approaches problems. However, personal details, payment information and order records generally belong in a suitable private conversation.

Explain the reason for moving channels and make the transition easy. Simply telling somebody to contact support can feel like starting over. A named contact or clear case reference helps connect the public acknowledgement with the practical work of resolving the issue.

Baer also advises limiting repetitive public exchanges. His rule of replying only twice is intended to prevent an endless argument. Treat that as a communication boundary, not a reason to abandon necessary follow-up through an appropriate channel.

Separate criticism from abusive conduct

A frustrated tone does not automatically make a complaint invalid. Read for the underlying facts and avoid responding defensively to every sharp phrase. At the same time, threats, harassment and repeated personal attacks require clear boundaries that protect employees.

A business can explain that it is willing to investigate the service issue while asking for respectful communication. Staff should know when to involve a manager and how to document a serious incident. Good service does not require an individual employee to manage every difficult situation alone.

Consistency matters here. Decisions should follow a clear approach rather than depend on whether a customer is especially loud, influential or persistent. Otherwise, the complaints process can become confusing for both customers and staff.

Turn repeated complaints into improvements

Review feedback for patterns. Several questions about an invoice may indicate unclear wording. Repeated delivery enquiries may point to an inadequate confirmation message. These patterns can reveal a change that prevents future problems instead of repeatedly treating the same symptom.

Choose an improvement, assign responsibility and check what happens afterward. If the invoice wording changes, monitor whether the same question continues to appear. Fewer complaints alone are not conclusive if customers have also stopped finding the contact form.

The aim is not to become every customer’s friend or to win every disagreement. It is to make the business dependable when something goes wrong. Listening, following through and learning from the result can turn uncomfortable feedback into useful work.

Online Solutions Group BV, led by owner Sergej Dergatsjev, has maintained CompanyGids for ten years and continues to develop the business directory. Find advertising, communication and marketing consultancies and software development companies on CompanyGids for business contacts. Explore digital services from OSG: contentmarketing.